Oct 03, 2006 07:49
Cliff's Notes:
The short version:
(1) Brando kills a game I mapped - no players in it, yet (no one complains - it is annoying, sure, but I simply let him map one)
(2) I kill the game Brando maps - players in game, but game is ruined by another player joining, taking bases, killing lgms, stealing pills - some players have quit and no one complains, including Brando: all players agree that game is over
(3) I am immediately banned by Jhood, without warning or discussion, and without anyone asking me to be banned (including Brando, the mapmaker)
(4) Hood gives reason for my ban as 'for killing a game i didn't spawn' (which is not a bannable offense)
(5) Hood gives reason for Brando's non-ban as 'because the game he killed wasn't passworded' (non-passworded games are treated identically in the rules as passworded games, so again: not relevant to banning)
(6) I contact Hood and complain about the situation - concerned about the issue, I also post it to the forums.
(7) Hood looks into the case and retroactively gives different reasons for banning me and not banning Brando.
(8) Hood later explains that the 'actual' reason he kicked/banned me was because I killed a 'game in progress' whereas the game he didn't kick/ban Brando for was not yet a 'game in progress' - even though these explanations run contrary to the original reasons he posted both in MIRC and to the ops forums concerning my ban and Bran's lack thereof.
Above all, if other ops acted like him, YOU TOO could be banned for killing a game you didn't map even if everyone in the game agrees it is over and just wants to start a new one! YOU TOO could have someone just kill the maps you make because they 'don't like them' and not even risk a ban by doing so!
*shrug* I leave it to you all to decide - does this make sense?
<Deramisan> acrobot mapnp fitzhu
<Acrobot> Fitzhu v3.map @ winbolo://24.195.41.47:59548 - strict for 10 gamers
<Brando> ew
<Brando> that map blows.
<Brando> acrobot kill 59548
<Acrobot> Game destruction commencing - please stand by. Brando killed game 59548 on 24.195.41.47
(1) Brando kills a game I mapped - no players in it, yet (no one complains - it is annoying, sure, but I simply let him map one)
(2) I kill the game Brando maps - players in game, but game is ruined by another player joining, taking bases, killing lgms, stealing pills - some players have quit and no one complains, including Brando: all players agree that game is over
(3) I am immediately banned by Jhood, without warning or discussion, and without anyone asking me to be banned (including Brando, the mapmaker)
(4) Hood gives reason for my ban as 'for killing a game i didn't spawn' (which is not a bannable offense)
(5) Hood gives reason for Brando's non-ban as 'because the game he killed wasn't passworded' (non-passworded games are treated identically in the rules as passworded games, so again: not relevant to banning)
(6) I contact Hood and complain about the situation - concerned about the issue, I also post it to the forums.
(7) Hood looks into the case and retroactively gives different reasons for banning me and not banning Brando.
(8) Hood later explains that the 'actual' reason he kicked/banned me was because I killed a 'game in progress' whereas the game he didn't kick/ban Brando for was not yet a 'game in progress' - even though these explanations run contrary to the original reasons he posted both in MIRC and to the ops forums concerning my ban and Bran's lack thereof.
Above all, if other ops acted like him, YOU TOO could be banned for killing a game you didn't map even if everyone in the game agrees it is over and just wants to start a new one! YOU TOO could have someone just kill the maps you make because they 'don't like them' and not even risk a ban by doing so!
*shrug* I leave it to you all to decide - does this make sense?
<Deramisan> acrobot mapnp fitzhu
<Acrobot> Fitzhu v3.map @ winbolo://24.195.41.47:59548 - strict for 10 gamers
<Brando> ew
<Brando> that map blows.
<Brando> acrobot kill 59548
<Acrobot> Game destruction commencing - please stand by. Brando killed game 59548 on 24.195.41.47
Last edited: Oct 03, 2006 08:08 (edited 1 time)